How these questions work on the LEAB
Problem sensitivity is recognising that a problem exists, not solving it. In one kind of question several witnesses describe the same suspect or event, and you find the account that differs from the rest. In the other you are given a procedure and an account of how an incident was handled, and you choose the most serious departure from the procedure.
Inductive reasoning is finding a rule or connection across separate events. Usually you get descriptions from several incidents and decide which could be the same person, ruled in or out by height, build, age and marks. Other questions give a log of incidents and ask for the pattern in time or place.
A method for accounts, procedures and suspects
Use the same steps every time:
- Compare witness accounts one detail at a time across all of them: age, height, clothing, footwear, direction. The odd account is the one that breaks a detail the others agree on.
- For a departure from procedure, rank by risk: danger to people first, then evidence, then paperwork.
- Rule suspects out on hard differences, such as a height several inches off, a different hair colour or a missing scar. Clothing changes easily, so do not rule anyone out on clothing alone.
- Allow for small differences in estimates. Witnesses judge age, height and weight roughly, so treat close figures as consistent.
- For an incident log, list the day, time and place of each entry before looking at the options.
Worked examples
Witness accounts. Four witnesses to a shoplifting describe the man. Witness 1: about 30, 5 ft 10, grey hooded top, white trainers. Witness 2: about 30, 6 ft, grey hooded top, white trainers. Witness 3: early thirties, 5 ft 11, grey hooded top, white trainers. Witness 4: about 30, 5 ft 10, grey hooded top, black boots. Which account most likely contains an error? Heights between 5 ft 10 and 6 ft are normal variation. Only the fourth breaks a detail the others share, the footwear, so the answer is Witness 4.
Suspect matching. A man arrested for a burglary is about 25, 5 ft 9, 170 lb, with black hair and a scar on his left hand. Report 1 describes a man of about 45; Report 2 a man of 5 ft 9 and 170 lb with blond hair; Report 3 a man in his mid twenties, about 5 ft 10 and 175 lb, with black hair and a scarred left hand, wearing a different jacket; Report 4 a man of 6 ft 3. Only Report 3 could be him: the small differences in height and weight are estimates, and the jacket can change. The others differ on age, hair or height.
Tips for the real test
- Read every account before deciding. The odd one out is defined by what the rest agree on.
- Ask which departure could get someone hurt or lose evidence. That is usually the most serious.
- Do not rule a suspect out on clothing or a slightly different estimate.
- Circle anything you skip in the booklet so you can find it in the last minutes.
- Fill every blank before time is called. There is no penalty for a wrong answer.
Practise on CogniPrep
Our drill gives you 16 questions in 30 minutes: four witness-account questions, four on departures from procedure, five suspect matches and three incident patterns. Witness accounts and suspect matches are generated fresh each sitting, so you practise the comparison rather than memorise answers. You can move freely, flag questions and check an answer grid, with no time warnings. Feedback shows which kinds of question cost you marks and what to change.