How UCAT Decision Making works
Decision Making is the longest subtest: 35 questions in 37 minutes. It tests whether you can reach sound conclusions from rules, arguments and data, and it mixes six kinds of question in random order.
Syllogisms and interpreting information give you some premises or a passage and five statements. You mark each statement Yes if it follows and No if it does not; in the real test you drag Yes and No into place. Logical puzzles, statistical reasoning, the strongest argument and Venn diagrams are multiple choice with one answer.
A multiple-choice question is worth 1 mark and a five-statement question 2. A partly correct five-statement answer earns 1 mark; the rule for partly correct is not published, and four of five right is the reported reading. A basic calculator is available, and in 2025 logical puzzles were the hardest type and Venn diagrams the easiest.
A method for each kind of question
Each type has a first move that saves time:
- Syllogisms: answer Yes only if the statement must be true from the premises. "Possible" is a No.
- Interpreting information: judge each statement against the passage alone, one at a time, without letting the last answer steer the next.
- Logical puzzles: write the rules down in shorthand, place the most restricted item first, and list the cases that remain.
- Statistical reasoning: write the fraction down before you touch the calculator, and check whether items are replaced.
- Strongest argument: pick the reason that is relevant to the question and true, not the one you agree with.
- Venn diagrams: read exactly which regions the question includes. "Only A" leaves out every overlap.
Worked examples
Syllogism. "All the lifeguards at the pool can swim 400 metres. Some people who can swim 400 metres coach on Saturdays. No one who coaches on Saturdays works the early shift." Does each statement follow? 1: Some lifeguards coach on Saturdays. No, it is possible but not certain. 2: Anyone at the pool who cannot swim 400 metres is not a lifeguard. Yes. 3: No lifeguard works the early shift. No, the lifeguards may not be the people who coach. 4: Some people who can swim 400 metres do not work the early shift. Yes, the ones who coach on Saturdays. 5: Everyone who can swim 400 metres is a lifeguard. No. All five right earns both marks.
Statistical reasoning. A bag holds 4 green and 6 yellow counters. Two are drawn at random without replacement. Is the chance that both are yellow greater than 1 in 3? A: Yes, it is 9/25. B: Yes, it is 3/5. C: No, it is exactly 1/3. D: No, it is 2/15. The chance is 6/10 × 5/9 = 30/90, which is exactly 1/3, so the answer is C. A is the trap: 9/25 is the answer if the first counter goes back in the bag.
Logical puzzle. Ana, Ben, Cy and Dee start shifts at 7, 8, 9 and 10. Ben starts before Cy, Ana starts at an odd hour, and Dee starts immediately after Ben. Who starts at 10? If Ana starts at 7, Ben and Dee must take 8 and 9, since 9 and 10 would leave Cy at 8, before Ben. If Ana starts at 9, Ben and Dee take 7 and 8. Either way Cy starts at 10.
Tips for the real test
- Fill every Yes or No row. A five-statement question with a row left blank cannot earn full marks.
- Flag a logical puzzle that is not coming out after a minute and a half, and come back to it from the review screen.
- Use the test centre notebook for Venn diagrams and puzzle grids. Drawing is faster than holding it in your head.
- Answer everything. There is no negative marking, so a guess on a question you would otherwise leave is free.
- The calculator has no single-digit delete: Backspace clears the whole entry, so do one-step sums in your head.
Practise UCAT Decision Making on CogniPrep
Our Decision Making test is free. It gives 35 questions of all six types in 37 minutes, with a basic calculator, flags and a review screen, and standard, 25%, 33% or 50% extra time. Five-statement questions are worth 2 marks, and four of five right earns 1, our estimate of the real partial credit; you tap Yes or No rather than dragging. Your result is an indicative score on the 300 to 900 scale, worked out from the consortium's published averages and not an official UCAT score, with a breakdown of which question types cost you marks.