How the Saville situational judgement test works
Each question sets out a situation you could meet in the job, in text, as images or as a short video. Several possible responses follow, and you rate every one on how effective it would be. Jaguar Land Rover’s guide described four responses per situation, each rated from Extremely ineffective to Extremely effective, with no time limit.
Most Saville SJTs are written for one employer, around its own situations and values. Saville also sells ready-made SJTs for manager, customer-facing, retail and logistics roles. Employers that describe using them include Jaguar Land Rover for graduates and apprentices, Fujitsu for its graduate scheme, Johnson & Johnson for early careers and Heathrow for security officers.
Your ratings are compared with the employer’s key: how effective that organisation judges each response to be. Ratings close to the key score well, so the test rewards reading the situation the way the employer does.
How to rate each response
Ask the same questions of every response:
- First decide whether the response helps at all. Rating a harmful response as slightly effective costs more than choosing the wrong degree of effective.
- Then decide how much. A response that deals with the whole problem rates higher than one that deals with part of it.
- Ask whether it is your call. Acting beyond your authority rarely rates well; passing on something you could fix yourself rarely rates at the top either.
- Rate each response on its own. More than one can be effective, and more than one can be poor.
- Use the ends of the scale when a response is clearly very good or clearly harmful.
Worked example
Situation: you work on a hotel front desk. A guest arrives upset because the sea-view room they booked has gone to someone else, and only rooms facing the car park are left tonight.
“Listen, say sorry for the mix-up, explain what is free and offer what you are allowed to, such as a lower rate tonight and a sea-view room tomorrow.” Extremely effective: it deals with the guest and the problem within your authority.
“Call the duty manager down to speak to the guest.” Slightly effective: it may help, but it hands over a problem you could handle.
“Move the guest into the most expensive suite free of charge without checking with anyone.” Ineffective: it pleases the guest but goes beyond your authority.
“Tell the guest the booking system made the error and there is nothing you can do.” Extremely ineffective: it leaves an upset guest with no help.
Tips for the real Saville situational judgement test
- Read the employer’s values and the job description first. The key reflects what that organisation wants, which can differ from one employer to the next.
- For a video SJT, use headphones and a quiet room, and watch each clip closely; tone and who is in the room can matter.
- Rate the response as written, not a better version of it you would do instead.
- If there is no clock, take the time to read every response before rating any.
- Ask the employer early if you need an adjustment, so it is in place before you begin.
Practise the Saville situational judgement test on CogniPrep
Our Situational Judgement game gives you 12 written scenarios drawn from a bank of 24, set in customer, team, manager and operations work, ordered from easier to harder. Each has four responses in a shuffled order, and you rate every one on six points from Extremely ineffective to Extremely effective. It is untimed. Each rating earns full credit on our key, two thirds one point away and a third two points away, and your score is the share of credit you earn. Feedback reads your result as a sten-style band against other CogniPrep candidates and names the kind of response you over-rate. The scenarios are written, not video, and our key and marking are our estimate, not an employer’s.