How Logic-Based Reasoning works
Each passage is a few sentences about agents, offices, cases or investigations, written as plain statements: all, no, some, if-then, only, more than, fewer than. Under it come one to four conclusions. For each you decide whether the passage proves it (True), rules it out (False) or leaves it open (Insufficient Information to Decide).
Use the passage alone. What is likely, or true of the real Secret Service, does not count. A conclusion that sounds sensible but is not forced by the statements is Insufficient.
Some passages also use likelihood words. Definitely means certain, more likely than not means over half, and less likely than not means under half.
A method for every passage
Use the same steps every time:
- Read the passage once, closely, then answer all its conclusions before moving on.
- "All A are B" does not mean all B are A. Write the arrow one way only.
- "No A are B" works both ways: no B are A either.
- "Some" means at least one, perhaps all. It never tells you that some are not.
- "If A, then B" lets you conclude "if not B, then not A", but nothing from B alone.
- Choose False only when the passage makes the conclusion impossible. If you can imagine it either way, the answer is Insufficient.
Worked example
Passage: "Every agent assigned to the Denver field office completed advanced firearms training this year. Some agents who completed advanced firearms training also completed protective driving training. No agent who completed protective driving training is assigned to the canine unit."
Conclusion 1: "Some agents assigned to the Denver field office completed protective driving training." Insufficient. The agents with both trainings may all work outside Denver.
Conclusion 2: "No agent assigned to the canine unit completed protective driving training." True. A "no" statement reverses.
Conclusion 3: "An agent assigned to the canine unit completed protective driving training." False. The passage rules it out.
Conclusion 4: "Every agent who completed advanced firearms training is assigned to the Denver field office." Insufficient. An "all" statement does not reverse.
Tips for the real test
- When you doubt Insufficient, it is usually right. Most errors come from marking True or False on what is merely likely.
- Read only, most and a few carefully. "Only A are B" means every B is an A, not the other way round.
- Keep to about 80 seconds a conclusion and leave time to check flagged ones.
- Answer every question. A wrong answer costs nothing more than a blank.
Practise on CogniPrep
Our free test is the full section: 12 passages and 30 conclusions in 40 minutes, with the same three options. Passages are generated fresh and every key is worked out from the statements, so a second sitting is a new paper. You can move between conclusions, flag them and check an answer grid. Feedback shows which statement types cost you marks and whether you lean towards True or False when the answer is Insufficient.