How the Mettl critical thinking test works
Each question gives a situation that sets out a premise, then four statements. Depending on the question, you decide which statements are assumptions the situation makes, which arguments are strong or weak, and which conclusions validly follow. Mettl also describes the test as covering deductions, inferences and interpretations.
Use only what the situation says. Background knowledge, however true, is not part of the premise.
How to judge each type
Each of the three types has its own test:
- Assumptions: something the writer takes for granted without saying it. Negate the statement: if the claim falls apart, it was assumed.
- Arguments: a strong argument is relevant to the question and important, not trivial. “Yes, because it has always been done” is weak.
- Conclusions: a valid conclusion follows from the situation alone. If you need an extra fact to get there, it does not follow.
- Watch for all, always and never in the statements: they usually claim more than the situation supports.
Worked examples
Assumption. A café chain will keep its city-centre branches open until midnight because evening footfall in the area has risen since a new cinema opened. Which of these is an assumption made? A: The extra evening visitors will spend enough to cover the cost of opening late. B: The cinema will close within a year. C: Other cafés nearby already open until midnight. D: Morning sales at the branches are falling.
A is assumed: if the extra visitors would not spend enough, the plan makes no sense. B works against the plan, and the plan needs neither C nor D. The answer is A.
Argument. Should the council close the old market street to cars at weekends? A: Yes, other towns have done it. B: Yes, it would make the street safer for shoppers on its busiest days. C: No, cars have always used the street. D: No, some drivers prefer that route. Which is the strongest argument?
B is relevant and important: safety on the busiest days goes to the heart of the question. A and C lean on what others do or have always done, and D is a minor preference. The answer is B.
Conclusion. In a survey of 400 staff at a firm, 300 said they would use a staff gym if one were built. Which conclusion follows? A: Most of the staff surveyed say they would use a gym. B: The firm will build a gym. C: Staff who exercise work harder. D: Most office workers in the city want a gym.
300 of 400 is 75%, so A follows. B is a decision the survey does not make, C brings in an outside idea, and D goes beyond the people surveyed. The answer is A.
Tips for the real critical thinking test
- Read the question line first, to know whether you are looking for an assumption, an argument or a conclusion.
- Keep to about 85 seconds a question. The situations are short, so most of the time goes on the four statements.
- Rule out statements that contradict the situation or bring in outside facts, then choose between the rest.
- Do not be thrown by a hard question: the test mixes easy, medium and difficult items. Flag it with Revisit and move on.
Practise Mettl Critical Thinking on CogniPrep
Our version has 21 questions on a 30-minute Test Time countdown at the top right, 7 each on assumptions, arguments and conclusions. Each gives a short situation and four statements, and you pick the one the question asks for; Mettl does not show its exact answer layout, so ours, and the 7 each split, are our estimate. The palette shows answered, Revisit, unanswered and not yet visited questions; Previous and Next move you along, Clear Response empties an answer, and Finish Test shows a summary and asks you to confirm. One mark per correct answer, nothing off for a wrong one, and a sten from 1 to 10 in Mettl’s Low, Moderate and High bands, set against CogniPrep users, not Mettl’s norm group. Questions are drawn fresh each sitting.