How these questions work on the NYPD exam
Deductive reasoning means applying a rule you are given to a case. The NYPD’s tutorial gives the definition of an offence and asks which situation is the best example of it, or gives a numbered procedure and asks what the officer should do, which form to file or which code to radio.
Inductive reasoning runs the other way, from several pieces of information to a conclusion. Four witnesses report slightly different licence plates for one van: which is most likely correct? Or a suspect description lists several features: which would help most to pick the right person out?
Problem sensitivity is noticing what is wrong: the witness statement that conflicts with the others, the neighbour whose time differs, or the routine task that hides a problem. Information ordering covers following steps in order, from the next step of a procedure to arithmetic worked without a calculator.
Every rule and procedure you need is in the question, and the ones on the test may not match real NYPD rules. Answer from the page.
A method for each kind of question
- Definitions: split the definition into its elements, then test every option against every element. One missing element rules it out.
- Procedures: find the step whose condition matches the case exactly, including any exception, before you look at the options.
- Most likely correct: compare each version with all the others, one character or detail at a time. The answer is the one closest to every other version.
- Most helpful feature: prefer what a person cannot change and few people share, such as a scar or a tattoo, over clothing, height or hair.
- Least accurate: line the statements up detail by detail (time, place, direction, description) and find the one that breaks from the rest.
- Sums: multiplication and division before addition, written out by hand.
Worked examples
Definition. "CRIMINAL TRESPASS: a person knowingly enters or remains in a fenced or posted area without permission." Which is the best example? A shopper who stays after closing because she lost track of time; a worker eating lunch in his own break room; a man who climbs a fence marked "No Entry" to sleep in a rail yard. Only the third meets every element: he knows he is entering, the area is fenced and posted, and he has no permission. The shopper did not stay knowingly, and the worker has permission.
Most likely correct. Four plates are reported for one van: 7KTR482, 7KTR428, 7KJR482 and 1KTR482. Each of the last three differs from 7KTR482 in one place, and from each other in two. So 7KTR482 is most likely correct.
Arithmetic. 8(4) + 2(20) + 10: multiply first, 32 + 40, then add 10, for 82.
Tips for the real test
- Read the whole definition or procedure before the options. Exceptions often come last.
- Do not answer from what you know of police work. The rules on the test may be invented.
- Work every sum on paper. Calculators are not permitted.
- On plates and descriptions, compare character by character rather than reading the whole string at once.
- Answer every question. DCAS publishes no penalty for a wrong answer.
Practise on CogniPrep
Our reasoning drill gives you 20 questions in 35 minutes across these four abilities: definitions, procedures and code tables, plates and identifying features, suspect matching, witness statements, procedure order and short sums. Procedures, plates and statements are generated fresh, so a second sitting is a new paper. You can move between questions and flag them, and feedback shows which kinds of question cost you marks.